Turtle Trading system

Turtle Trading System

The Turtle Trading System is a renowned trend-following system developed in the 1980s by Richard Dennis, a highly successful commodity trader, and William "Bill" Eckhardt. It gained notoriety through the "Turtle Experiment," where Dennis sought to prove that successful trading was a skill that could be taught, rather than an innate talent. This article will delve into the intricacies of the Turtle Trading System, its principles, rules, risk management, and its relevance in modern markets. We will explore both the original system and adaptations used by traders today.

The Turtle Experiment

In 1983, Richard Dennis placed an advertisement seeking individuals to train as traders. He wasn’t looking for experienced traders, but rather individuals with a willingness to learn and follow rules. He selected 14 "Turtles" from a pool of over 100 applicants. These individuals came from diverse backgrounds, with no prior trading experience. Dennis and Eckhardt then provided the Turtles with a comprehensive trading education, centered around a specific set of rules – the Turtle Trading System.

The experiment aimed to determine whether trading success was based on talent or a disciplined, rules-based approach. The results were remarkable. Within a short period, the Turtles were consistently profitable, demonstrating the power of a well-defined system and proper risk management. Many Turtles went on to have successful careers in trading, further validating Dennis's hypothesis. The experiment is a cornerstone in the study of Trading Psychology and the importance of systematic trading.

Core Principles of the Turtle Trading System

The Turtle Trading System is fundamentally a trend-following system. This means it aims to identify and capitalize on existing trends in the market, rather than attempting to predict reversals or pick tops and bottoms. Here are the core principles:

Trend Following: The system is built on the belief that trends tend to persist for longer than most traders expect. It focuses on identifying and riding these trends.
Mechanical Rule-Based Trading: The system is entirely rule-based, eliminating emotional decision-making. Every entry and exit is defined by specific criteria. This is crucial for Discipline in Trading.
Risk Management: Rigorous risk management is paramount. The system incorporates strict rules for position sizing and stop-loss orders to limit potential losses. This aligns with sound Risk Reward Ratio principles.
Diversification: The original Turtles traded multiple markets (commodities, currencies, and futures) to diversify their risk.
Patience and Discipline: Successful implementation requires unwavering patience and discipline to follow the rules, even during periods of drawdown.

The System's Rules

The Turtle Trading System consists of several interconnected rules, categorized into Entry Rules, Exit Rules, and Risk Management Rules.

Entry Rules

The entry rules are designed to identify potential trend-following opportunities. The Turtles primarily used a 55-day moving average and a 20-day moving average to determine breakout points.

Long Entry (Buying): A long entry is triggered when the price breaks above the previous 20-day high. This 20-day high must also be the highest high of the previous 55 days. This confirms a significant breakout. The system utilizes the concept of Support and Resistance to identify these key levels.
Short Entry (Selling): A short entry is triggered when the price breaks below the previous 20-day low. This 20-day low must also be the lowest low of the previous 55 days. Similar to the long entry, this signifies a significant breakdown. Understanding Bearish Patterns is vital here.
Breakout Confirmation: The 55-day rule is crucial. It filters out false breakouts, ensuring the breakout is significant and has momentum.

Exit Rules

The exit rules determine when to take profits or cut losses. These rules are equally as important as the entry rules.

Trailing Stop Loss: The primary exit rule is a trailing stop-loss. The initial stop-loss is placed a certain number of ticks (depending on the market) below the entry price for long positions and above the entry price for short positions. As the price moves in your favor, the stop-loss is adjusted upwards (for long positions) or downwards (for short positions) to lock in profits. The Turtles used a variety of trailing stop-loss techniques including fixed percentage trailing stops and volatility-based trailing stops (using the Average True Range or ATR).
Profit Target (Optional): While the primary focus was on trailing stops, some Turtles also used profit targets, although these were less emphasized.
Time Stop (Optional): Some Turtles also implemented time stops, exiting a trade if it did not move in their favor within a specified timeframe.

Risk Management Rules

These are arguably the most critical rules of the system. The Turtles understood that preserving capital is paramount.

Position Sizing: The system uses a fixed fractional position sizing rule. Typically, traders risked 1-2% of their total capital on any single trade. This is based on the distance between the entry price and the initial stop-loss. Proper Position Sizing Strategies are essential.
Maximum Drawdown: The Turtles had a predefined maximum drawdown limit. If their account equity fell below this limit, they would reduce their position size until they recovered.
Market Diversification: Trading multiple markets simultaneously helps to reduce overall portfolio risk. Correlation analysis between markets is important here. Understanding Portfolio Management is crucial.
No Martingaling: The system strictly prohibits increasing position size after a loss (martingale strategy), as this can quickly lead to ruin.

Modern Adaptations and Considerations

While the original Turtle Trading System was developed for futures markets, its principles can be adapted for various markets, including stocks, forex, and cryptocurrencies. However, some modifications may be necessary.

Timeframe Adjustments: The 55-day and 20-day moving averages may need to be adjusted based on the timeframe of the market being traded. For example, day traders might use shorter moving averages. The concept of Time Frame Analysis is key.
Volatility Adjustments: The fixed stop-loss distance may need to be adjusted based on the volatility of the market. More volatile markets require wider stop-losses. The Bollinger Bands indicator can assist in assessing volatility.
Commission and Slippage: Modern traders need to account for commission and slippage, which can significantly impact profitability, especially with frequent trading.
Backtesting and Optimization: Before implementing the system, it's crucial to backtest it on historical data to evaluate its performance and optimize the parameters. Backtesting Strategies and understanding Statistical Significance are essential.
Market Regime Changes: The system may perform differently in different market regimes (trending vs. ranging). Market Cycle Analysis can help traders adapt their strategies accordingly.
Incorporating Other Indicators: Some traders incorporate other technical indicators, such as RSI, MACD, and Fibonacci Retracements, to confirm entries and exits. However, it’s important to avoid overcomplicating the system.
Automated Trading: The rule-based nature of the system makes it suitable for automated trading using trading bots. Algorithmic Trading can improve execution speed and consistency.

Advantages of the Turtle Trading System

Simplicity: The system is relatively simple to understand and implement.
Objectivity: The rule-based approach eliminates emotional bias.
Robustness: The system has proven to be robust over time and across various markets.
Scalability: The system can be scaled to trade larger positions as capital grows.
Risk Management: The strict risk management rules protect against significant losses.

Disadvantages of the Turtle Trading System

Whipsaws: The system can generate false signals during choppy or sideways markets, leading to whipsaws (small losses).
Lagging Indicator: Moving averages are lagging indicators, meaning they react to price changes rather than predicting them.
Requires Discipline: The system requires unwavering discipline to follow the rules, even during periods of drawdown.
Not Suitable for All Markets: The system may not perform well in markets that are not trending.
Potential for Drawdowns: Trend-following systems can experience significant drawdowns during market corrections. Understanding Drawdown Management is vital.

Comparing to Other Trading Systems

The Turtle Trading System differs significantly from other popular trading systems. Compared to Day Trading, which focuses on short-term price movements, the Turtle System is a longer-term trend-following strategy. Unlike Swing Trading, which attempts to capture short-term swings, the Turtle System seeks to ride sustained trends. Compared to Value Investing, which focuses on fundamental analysis, the Turtle System is purely technical. It's also distinct from Scalping, which aims to profit from very small price movements.

Resources for Further Learning

The New Turtle Trader: Rules to Win at Life & Money by Michael Covel: A comprehensive book on the Turtle Trading System.
Way of the Turtle by Curtis Faith: Another insightful book written by one of the original Turtles.
Trading in the Zone by Mark Douglas: A classic book on trading psychology.
Technical Analysis of the Financial Markets by John J. Murphy: A comprehensive guide to technical analysis.
Investopedia: Turtle Trading - A good overview of the system.
Babypips: Turtle Trading Strategy - A beginner-friendly guide.
StockCharts.com: Turtle Trading System - Explanation of the system with examples.
Trend Following by Michael Covel: Trend Following - Website dedicated to trend following strategies.
TradingView: TradingView - Platform for charting and backtesting.
QuantConnect: QuantConnect - Platform for algorithmic trading.

The Turtle Trading System remains a relevant and valuable system for traders today. Its emphasis on discipline, risk management, and trend following are timeless principles that can improve trading performance. While it requires dedication and patience, the system's proven track record makes it a worthy consideration for anyone seeking a systematic approach to trading. Mastering Candlestick Patterns can also enhance entry and exit point accuracy.

Start Trading Now

Sign up at IQ Option (Minimum deposit $10) Open an account at Pocket Option (Minimum deposit $5)

Join Our Community

Subscribe to our Telegram channel @strategybin to receive: ✓ Daily trading signals ✓ Exclusive strategy analysis ✓ Market trend alerts ✓ Educational materials for beginners