Says Law

Says Law

Says Law (often called Say's Law of Markets) is a fundamental economic principle stating that the supply of goods creates its own demand. It's a cornerstone concept in classical economics, often contrasted with Keynesian economics, and understanding it is crucial for grasping broader macroeconomic theories. This article will provide a detailed exploration of Says Law, its historical context, underlying assumptions, criticisms, modern interpretations, and its relevance to Technical Analysis and Trading Strategies.

Historical Context and Jean-Baptiste Say

The law is named after the French economist Jean-Baptiste Say (1767-1832). Say formulated his principle in his 1803 work, *A Treatise on Political Economy*. However, the idea wasn't entirely new; elements of it can be traced back to earlier economists like John Law (though their contexts differed significantly). Say wasn’t claiming an absolute, universally applicable truth, but rather observing a consistent pattern in a functioning market economy. He argued that the very act of producing goods and services generates the income necessary to purchase those goods and services. This income is distributed as wages, profits, rent, and interest to the factors of production (labor, capital, land, and entrepreneurship).

Say’s observations stemmed from a time before the widespread use of money and the complexities of modern financial systems. He noticed that, in barter economies, the value of what is produced *is* the means to purchase what is produced. Even when money is introduced, Say argued, it merely facilitates the exchange but doesn’t fundamentally change the relationship between production and demand. The focus was on real goods and services, not abstract financial instruments.

He presented this principle as a counterargument to the Malthusian school of thought, which predicted inevitable overproduction and economic stagnation due to population growth outpacing food supply. Say believed that overproduction was not a general phenomenon but rather a temporary imbalance in specific markets, which would correct itself through price adjustments and resource reallocation.

The Core Principle Explained

At its core, Says Law posits that "supply creates its own demand." This doesn't mean that people will desire *everything* that is produced. Instead, it means that the total value of goods and services produced in an economy will, in aggregate, generate sufficient income to purchase all that is produced.

Here’s a breakdown of the logic:

1. **Production Generates Income:** When a firm produces goods or services, it must pay for the factors of production:

  * **Wages:** Payment to labor.
  * **Profits:** Return to capital.
  * **Rent:** Payment for land.
  * **Interest:** Return on borrowed capital.

2. **Income Equals Purchasing Power:** These payments (wages, profits, rent, and interest) represent income for individuals and businesses. This income provides the purchasing power to buy the goods and services that were produced.

3. **Aggregate Demand:** The sum of all individual and business incomes constitutes aggregate demand. Say's Law argues that this aggregate demand will be equal to the aggregate supply (the total value of goods and services produced).

Therefore, a general overproduction is considered impossible because the act of producing creates the means to consume. Any surplus in one market will be offset by a shortage in another. Resources will naturally flow from areas of low profitability to areas of high profitability, correcting imbalances. This links strongly to the concept of Market Equilibrium.

Assumptions Underlying Says Law

Says Law relies on several key assumptions, which are critical to its validity:

**Flexible Prices and Wages:** The law assumes that prices and wages are flexible and can adjust quickly to changes in supply and demand. If there’s a surplus of a particular good, its price will fall, making it more attractive to consumers and restoring equilibrium. Similarly, if there’s a shortage, the price will rise.
**No Significant Money Illusion:** The assumption is that people make economic decisions based on real values (the purchasing power of money) rather than nominal values (the face value of money). If people are fooled by changes in the money supply (a phenomenon known as Inflation) and misinterpret them as changes in real wealth, the law may not hold.
**Neutral Money:** Money is considered a neutral medium of exchange, simply facilitating transactions without affecting the underlying real economy. This means changes in the money supply don’t alter the fundamental relationship between production and demand.
**Rational Economic Actors:** Individuals and businesses are assumed to act rationally in their own self-interest, maximizing their utility and profits.
**Absence of Significant Barriers to Trade:** Free markets and minimal government intervention are assumed, allowing for the smooth flow of goods, services, and resources. Protectionism and excessive regulation can distort market signals and hinder the self-correcting mechanisms of Says Law.
**Full Employment (or a tendency towards it):** The law works best when the economy is operating near full employment. Persistent unemployment reduces aggregate income and, therefore, aggregate demand.
**Absence of Saving Hoarding:** Say initially believed that savings would automatically be invested, maintaining the flow of income. However, he later acknowledged the possibility of hoarding (saving without investing), which could potentially disrupt the cycle. This is a crucial point that Keynes later exploited.

Criticisms and the Keynesian Revolution

Says Law came under severe criticism during the Great Depression of the 1930s, largely due to the work of John Maynard Keynes. Keynes argued that Says Law was a poor explanation for prolonged economic downturns characterized by mass unemployment and deficient aggregate demand.

Keynes’s main arguments against Says Law were:

**The Paradox of Thrift:** Keynes argued that increased saving can actually *reduce* aggregate demand. If everyone tries to save more, they will spend less, leading to a decrease in income for others, and ultimately a lower level of overall consumption. This contradicts the idea that savings automatically translate into investment.
**Sticky Prices and Wages:** Keynes pointed out that prices and wages are often "sticky" – they don’t adjust immediately to changes in supply and demand. This is due to factors like labor contracts, menu costs (the cost of changing prices), and psychological resistance to wage cuts. Sticky prices prevent the self-correcting mechanisms of Says Law from functioning effectively.
**Animal Spirits and Investment:** Keynes emphasized the role of "animal spirits" – psychological factors and investor confidence – in driving investment. During times of uncertainty, businesses may be reluctant to invest, even if interest rates are low, leading to a decline in aggregate demand.
**The Role of Government Intervention:** Keynes advocated for government intervention, through fiscal and monetary policy, to stimulate aggregate demand during recessions and depressions. This directly challenged the classical belief in laissez-faire economics.

Keynes’s ideas led to a revolution in macroeconomic thought and the development of Keynesian Economics, which became the dominant paradigm for much of the 20th century. This shift highlighted the importance of Demand-Side Economics.

Modern Interpretations and Synthesis

While Keynesian economics gained prominence, Says Law hasn't been entirely discarded. Modern economists recognize that both supply and demand play crucial roles in determining economic outcomes.

Several modern interpretations attempt to reconcile Says Law with Keynesian insights:

**Long-Run vs. Short-Run:** Some economists argue that Says Law holds in the long run, while Keynesian principles are more relevant in the short run. In the long run, flexible prices and wages will eventually restore equilibrium, but in the short run, rigidities and psychological factors can lead to prolonged imbalances.
**Supply-Side Economics:** The rise of Supply-Side Economics in the 1980s, associated with figures like Arthur Laffer and Ronald Reagan, partially revived the spirit of Says Law. Supply-side economists argue that reducing taxes and regulations can stimulate production and investment, leading to economic growth.
**Real Business Cycle Theory:** This theory emphasizes the role of real shocks (changes in technology, productivity, or resource availability) in driving business cycles. It argues that the economy tends to self-correct and that government intervention is often counterproductive.
**The Importance of Relative Prices:** Modern interpretations focus on the importance of *relative* prices rather than absolute price levels. If the price of a particular good is too high relative to others, demand will fall, and resources will be reallocated.

The modern consensus is that a healthy economy requires both strong supply-side fundamentals (productivity, innovation, and efficient resource allocation) and adequate aggregate demand. Ignoring either side can lead to economic problems. A balanced approach is crucial for sustained economic growth.

Relevance to Trading Strategies and Technical Analysis

Understanding Says Law can inform trading strategies, particularly when analyzing economic cycles and market sentiment.

**Economic Cycle Analysis:** If an economy is experiencing strong supply-side growth (e.g., increased productivity, technological innovation), it may be a favorable environment for investing in growth stocks and cyclical industries. The expectation is that increased production will eventually translate into increased demand.
**Interest Rate Sensitivity:** Says Law suggests that increased savings should lead to lower interest rates, stimulating investment. Traders can monitor interest rate movements and adjust their portfolios accordingly. However, the Keynesian critique reminds us that savings may not always be invested, particularly during times of uncertainty.
**Inflationary Pressures:** If aggregate demand exceeds aggregate supply, inflationary pressures may arise. Traders can use Inflation Indicators like the Consumer Price Index (CPI) and Producer Price Index (PPI) to identify potential inflationary trends and adjust their trading strategies.
**Market Sentiment Analysis:** Keynesian economics highlights the importance of “animal spirits.” Traders can use Sentiment Analysis tools and techniques to gauge investor confidence and identify potential market turning points.
**Supply Chain Analysis:** Understanding the supply side of the equation is crucial. Monitoring Supply Chain Management and identifying potential disruptions can provide valuable trading opportunities. For example, shortages of key commodities can lead to price increases.
**Sector Rotation Strategies:** Says Law can help inform sector rotation strategies. In an expanding economy, cyclical sectors (e.g., industrials, materials, consumer discretionary) tend to outperform defensive sectors (e.g., utilities, healthcare).
**Using Economic Indicators:** Leading Economic Indicators such as the Purchasing Managers' Index (PMI) can provide insights into future economic activity and potential changes in supply and demand.
**Trend Following:** Identifying long-term trends in economic growth and productivity can inform trend-following Trading Systems.
**Value Investing:** Identifying undervalued companies with strong supply-side fundamentals can be a profitable value investing strategy.
**Fibonacci Retracements:** While not directly linked to Says Law, understanding market corrections following periods of strong supply-side growth can be analyzed using Fibonacci Retracements to identify potential entry points.
**Moving Averages:** Utilizing Moving Averages to smooth out price data and identify trends can complement economic analysis based on Says Law.
**Bollinger Bands:** Bollinger Bands can help traders identify potential overbought or oversold conditions, which may signal a correction in prices due to imbalances in supply and demand.
**Relative Strength Index (RSI):** RSI can indicate whether an asset is overvalued or undervalued, providing insights into potential market corrections based on supply and demand dynamics.
**MACD (Moving Average Convergence Divergence):** MACD can help identify changes in the strength, direction, momentum, and duration of a trend, reflecting shifts in supply and demand.
**Ichimoku Cloud:** The Ichimoku Cloud provides a comprehensive view of support and resistance levels, momentum, and trend direction, aiding in the analysis of supply and demand forces.
**Elliott Wave Theory:** Elliott Wave Theory attempts to identify recurring patterns in price movements based on investor psychology and collective sentiment, which can influence supply and demand.
**Point and Figure Charting:** Point and Figure Charting focuses on significant price movements and can help identify key support and resistance levels, reflecting supply and demand dynamics.
**Candlestick Patterns:** Analyzing Candlestick Patterns can provide insights into market sentiment and potential reversals in price trends, reflecting shifts in supply and demand.
**Volume Analysis:** Monitoring Volume can confirm the strength of price trends and identify potential divergences, indicating imbalances in supply and demand.
**On-Balance Volume (OBV):** OBV uses volume flow to predict price changes, reflecting the relationship between supply and demand.
**Accumulation/Distribution Line (A/D Line):** The A/D Line measures the flow of money into and out of a security, providing insights into supply and demand pressures.
**Chaikin Oscillator:** Chaikin Oscillator measures the momentum of the A/D Line, indicating potential buying or selling pressure.
**Money Flow Index (MFI):** MFI combines price and volume data to identify overbought or oversold conditions, reflecting imbalances in supply and demand.
**Keltner Channels:** Keltner Channels help identify volatility and potential breakout opportunities, reflecting shifts in supply and demand.
**Parabolic SAR:** Parabolic SAR helps identify potential trend reversals, signaling changes in supply and demand dynamics.

Conclusion

Says Law remains a valuable, albeit contested, concept in economics. While the Keynesian revolution challenged its absolute validity, the principle that supply creates its own demand continues to offer insights into the functioning of market economies. Modern interpretations recognize the importance of both supply and demand and the need for a balanced approach to economic policy. Understanding Says Law can provide traders with a framework for analyzing economic cycles, market sentiment, and potential trading opportunities, especially when combined with Fundamental Analysis and Technical Analysis.

Macroeconomics Microeconomics Classical Economics Keynesian Economics Supply-Side Economics Demand-Side Economics Market Equilibrium Inflation Economic Indicators Trading Strategies

Start Trading Now

Sign up at IQ Option (Minimum deposit $10) Open an account at Pocket Option (Minimum deposit $5)

Join Our Community

Subscribe to our Telegram channel @strategybin to receive: ✓ Daily trading signals ✓ Exclusive strategy analysis ✓ Market trend alerts ✓ Educational materials for beginners