Prospect theory

Prospect Theory: Understanding How People Make Decisions Under Risk

Prospect theory is a behavioral economic theory describing how people make choices between probabilistic alternatives where the risk is uncertain. Developed by psychologists Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky in 1979, it is a cornerstone of understanding why people often deviate from the predictions of rational choice theory. Unlike traditional economic models that assume individuals are rational actors seeking to maximize expected utility, prospect theory acknowledges the influence of cognitive biases and psychological factors on decision-making. This article will delve into the core principles of prospect theory, its key components, and its implications for understanding financial decision-making, trading psychology, and everyday life. We will also explore how understanding prospect theory can improve your Trading psychology and strategy development.

The Core Principles of Prospect Theory

At its heart, prospect theory argues that individuals evaluate potential losses and gains differently and are more sensitive to losses than to equivalent gains. This asymmetry in how we perceive gains and losses is known as **loss aversion**. This fundamental principle, along with others, distinguishes prospect theory from expected utility theory.

**Loss Aversion:** As mentioned, people feel the pain of a loss more strongly than the pleasure of an equivalent gain. This isn't a simple preference; it's an asymmetrical weighting. For example, losing $100 is generally felt more intensely than gaining $100. This impacts risk-taking behavior, often leading individuals to avoid risks even when the potential gains outweigh the potential losses. In Risk management, understanding loss aversion is critical for setting realistic stop-loss orders.
**Framing Effects:** The way information is presented (or "framed") significantly influences choices. A decision framed as a potential gain is approached differently than the same decision framed as a potential loss, even if the objective outcomes are identical. For instance, a medical procedure with a "90% survival rate" is viewed more favorably than one with a "10% mortality rate," despite conveying the same information. This ties directly into Market psychology and how news events are interpreted.
**Reference Dependence:** People don't evaluate outcomes in absolute terms; they evaluate them relative to a **reference point**. This reference point is usually the current state of affairs, or a perceived status quo. Gains and losses are defined *relative* to this reference point. A $10 gain when your reference point is $0 is perceived differently than a $10 gain when your reference point is $1000. Understanding this is vital when analyzing Support and resistance levels.
**Diminishing Sensitivity:** The marginal impact of gains and losses diminishes as the size of the gain or loss increases. The difference between gaining $10 and $20 feels more significant than the difference between gaining $1000 and $1010. This explains why people often seek bigger gains as they accumulate wealth, but are less upset by small losses when they are already wealthy. This relates to concepts of Scaling in trading.
**Probability Weighting:** People don’t perceive and evaluate probabilities linearly. Small probabilities are often *overweighted* (e.g., people buy lottery tickets despite the incredibly low odds), while moderate to high probabilities are often *underweighted*. This distortion of probability perception influences risk-taking behavior. A 1% chance of winning $1 million may seem more attractive than it rationally should, while a 99% chance of winning $100 might seem less appealing than it rationally should. This explains the popularity of Options trading strategies with high potential payouts.

The Value Function

Prospect theory is mathematically represented by a **value function** (V(x)) that differs from the utility function used in expected utility theory. The value function has the following key characteristics:

It is **S-shaped**: Reflecting loss aversion and diminishing sensitivity.
It is **defined relative to a reference point**: The zero point represents the status quo.
It is **steeper for losses than for gains**: Illustrating loss aversion.

Mathematically, the value function can be approximated as:

V(x) = k * [x^α if x ≥ 0] - λ * [-x]^β if x < 0

Where:

x = the gain or loss relative to the reference point
k = a scaling factor for gains
λ = the loss aversion coefficient (typically greater than 1, representing that losses loom larger than gains)
α = the exponent for gains (typically between 0 and 1, reflecting diminishing sensitivity)
β = the exponent for losses (typically between 0 and 1, reflecting diminishing sensitivity)

The values of k, λ, α, and β are empirically determined and can vary between individuals. The loss aversion coefficient (λ) is particularly important, as it quantifies the degree to which people are more sensitive to losses than gains. Studies suggest λ is typically around 2.25, meaning losses are felt about 2.25 times more strongly than equivalent gains.

Applying Prospect Theory to Financial Markets

Prospect theory has significant implications for understanding investor behavior and market anomalies. Several common biases observed in financial markets can be explained by the principles of prospect theory:

**The Disposition Effect:** Investors tend to sell winning investments too early and hold onto losing investments for too long. This is driven by loss aversion. Selling a winning investment realizes a gain, but also eliminates the possibility of further gains. Selling a losing investment realizes a loss, which is psychologically painful. Investors hope that losing investments will "recover," avoiding the immediate pain of recognizing the loss. This can be counterproductive and lead to missed opportunities. This relates to the concept of Greed and fear in trading.
**Mental Accounting:** Investors often compartmentalize their finances into separate "mental accounts" and treat money differently depending on which account it belongs to. For example, money earmarked for a vacation might be spent more freely than money saved for retirement. This can lead to irrational investment decisions. Understanding Position sizing can help overcome mental accounting biases.
**The House Money Effect:** After experiencing gains, investors may become more risk-seeking, as they feel they are "playing with the house's money." This can lead to increased risk-taking and potentially larger losses. This is often observed after a winning streak in trading. Drawdown management is essential to mitigate the house money effect.
**Regret Aversion:** Investors often avoid making decisions that could lead to regret, even if those decisions are rationally sound. This can lead to inaction or suboptimal investment choices. For example, an investor might avoid selling a losing stock because they fear regretting the sale if the stock subsequently rebounds. This ties into Confirmation bias.
**Myopic Loss Aversion:** Frequent evaluation of investment portfolios exacerbates loss aversion. The more often investors check their portfolios, the more likely they are to focus on short-term losses, leading to panic selling and suboptimal long-term returns. This highlights the importance of a long-term investment horizon and avoiding excessive monitoring. This concept is closely related to Dollar-cost averaging.

Prospect Theory and Trading Strategies

Understanding prospect theory can inform the development and implementation of more effective trading strategies:

**Accepting Losses:** Recognizing loss aversion allows traders to develop a more disciplined approach to loss-cutting. Setting predefined stop-loss orders based on technical analysis (e.g., Moving average crossovers, Fibonacci retracements, Bollinger Bands) can help mitigate the emotional impact of losses and prevent them from escalating.
**Realistic Profit Targets:** Diminishing sensitivity suggests that traders should set realistic profit targets. Chasing excessively large gains can lead to missed opportunities and increased risk.
**Framing Positions:** Traders can frame their positions in a way that minimizes the psychological impact of losses. For example, focusing on the potential upside of a trade rather than the potential downside can help maintain a rational perspective.
**Avoiding Overconfidence:** The house money effect cautions against becoming overconfident after experiencing gains. Maintaining a disciplined risk management approach is crucial, regardless of recent performance.
**Long-Term Perspective:** Myopic loss aversion emphasizes the importance of a long-term investment horizon. Avoiding frequent portfolio evaluations can help reduce the emotional impact of short-term market fluctuations. Trend following strategies often benefit from a long-term perspective.
**Using Candlestick patterns**: Recognizing patterns that signal potential reversals can help traders anticipate and manage losses more effectively.
**Implementing Elliott Wave Theory**: Understanding wave structures can help traders identify potential turning points and manage risk accordingly.
**Employing Ichimoku Cloud**: This indicator provides comprehensive support and resistance levels, aiding in setting realistic profit targets and stop-loss orders.
**Analyzing Relative Strength Index (RSI)**: RSI helps identify overbought and oversold conditions, assisting in making informed trading decisions.
**Utilizing MACD**: MACD can signal potential trend changes, helping traders adjust their strategies and manage risk.
**Considering Volume Spread Analysis (VSA)**: VSA provides insights into market sentiment and potential price movements.
**Applying Chart patterns**: Recognizing patterns like head and shoulders or double tops/bottoms can help identify potential trading opportunities and manage risk.
**Leveraging Harmonic Patterns**: These patterns offer precise entry and exit points based on Fibonacci ratios.
**Integrating Intermarket Analysis**: Analyzing correlations between different markets can provide valuable insights.
**Employing Wyckoff Method**: This method focuses on understanding market structure and identifying accumulation/distribution phases.
**Using Point and Figure charting**: This charting method filters out noise and focuses on significant price movements.
**Analyzing On Balance Volume (OBV)**: OBV helps confirm trends and identify potential reversals.
**Considering Average Directional Index (ADX)**: ADX measures trend strength, assisting in identifying trading opportunities.
**Utilizing Parabolic SAR**: Parabolic SAR helps identify potential trend reversals.
**Applying Donchian Channels**: These channels identify breakout opportunities and potential trend changes.
**Integrating Keltner Channels**: Similar to Bollinger Bands, Keltner Channels provide insights into volatility and potential trading opportunities.
**Using Pivot Points**: Pivot points identify potential support and resistance levels.
**Analyzing Stochastic Oscillator**: This oscillator helps identify overbought and oversold conditions.
**Considering Commodity Channel Index (CCI)**: CCI helps identify cyclical trends and potential trading opportunities.
**Employing Fractals**: Fractals identify potential turning points in price action.
**Utilizing Heikin Ashi**: This charting method smooths price action and helps identify trends.
**Analyzing Renko charts**: Renko charts filter out noise and focus on significant price movements.

Criticisms and Limitations

While prospect theory has revolutionized behavioral economics and finance, it's not without its criticisms:

**Complexity:** The value function and weighting function can be complex to estimate and apply in practice.
**Individual Differences:** The parameters of the value function (k, λ, α, β) can vary significantly between individuals, making it difficult to generalize findings.
**Context Dependence:** The reference point can be subjective and influenced by the context of the decision.
**Limited Predictive Power:** Prospect theory doesn't always accurately predict behavior in all situations.

Despite these limitations, prospect theory remains a valuable framework for understanding how people make decisions under risk and uncertainty.

Conclusion

Prospect theory provides a powerful lens through which to understand the psychological factors that influence financial decision-making. By acknowledging the influence of loss aversion, framing effects, and other biases, traders and investors can develop more rational and disciplined strategies, ultimately improving their long-term performance. Understanding these principles isn’t just about improving trading outcomes; it’s about gaining a deeper understanding of human behavior itself. Furthermore, the application of Technical indicators alongside prospect theory can provide a robust framework for navigating the complexities of the financial markets.

Behavioral Finance Cognitive Bias Heuristics Decision Making Trading Psychology Risk Management Market Psychology Rational Choice Theory Expected Utility Theory Loss Aversion

Start Trading Now

Sign up at IQ Option (Minimum deposit $10) Open an account at Pocket Option (Minimum deposit $5)

Join Our Community

Subscribe to our Telegram channel @strategybin to receive: ✓ Daily trading signals ✓ Exclusive strategy analysis ✓ Market trend alerts ✓ Educational materials for beginners