MSCI Islamic Indexes methodology

1. MSCI Islamic Indexes Methodology

1. 1. Introduction

MSCI Islamic Indexes are a suite of equity, fixed income, and real estate indexes designed to represent the performance of publicly traded securities that comply with principles of Islamic finance, commonly known as *Sharia*. These indexes serve as benchmarks for Islamic investment funds and are utilized by investors seeking to align their investments with their religious beliefs. This article provides a comprehensive overview of the methodology employed in constructing these indexes, detailing the screening process, weighting rules, and ongoing maintenance procedures. Understanding this methodology is crucial for anyone involved in Islamic Finance or considering investments in Islamic equity markets.

1. 1. The Principles of Sharia Compliance

At the core of MSCI Islamic Indexes lies adherence to the principles of Sharia law, as interpreted by a panel of leading Islamic scholars. These principles broadly govern aspects of permissible (Halal) and prohibited (Haram) activities. Key considerations include:

• **Prohibition of *Riba* (Interest):** Sharia strictly prohibits the charging or paying of interest. This is a fundamental principle impacting all aspects of Islamic finance.
• **Prohibition of *Gharar* (Uncertainty):** Excessive uncertainty or speculation is deemed unacceptable. This impacts derivative instruments and complex financial arrangements. See also Risk Management.
• **Prohibition of *Maisir* (Gambling):** Investments involving gambling or games of chance are prohibited.
• **Permissible Activities:** Businesses involved in permissible activities, such as manufacturing, services, and ethical trade, are generally considered compliant.
• **Ethical Considerations:** Companies involved in activities deemed unethical, such as alcohol, tobacco, gambling, pork, and conventional financial institutions (banks, insurance), are typically excluded. This often overlaps with ESG Investing.

1. 1. MSCI Islamic Index Methodology: A Detailed Breakdown

The MSCI Islamic Index methodology involves a multi-stage screening process, followed by weighting and rebalancing procedures.

1. 1. 1. Stage 1: Initial Universe Selection

The process begins with defining the eligible initial universe of securities. MSCI typically starts with the MSCI All Country World Index (ACWI) or relevant regional/country indexes as the base universe. This universe is then subjected to a series of filters.

1. 1. 1. Stage 2: Business Line Screening

This is the most critical and comprehensive stage, involving a detailed analysis of each company's primary business activities. MSCI employs a proprietary Business Line Classification (BLC) system to categorize companies based on their revenue streams. Companies are screened based on the following criteria:

• **Prohibited Business Activities:** Companies deriving a significant portion of their revenue from prohibited activities are excluded. The specific revenue thresholds vary but generally aim to exclude companies with substantial exposure to Haram sectors. These sectors include:

   *   **Conventional Financial Services:** Banks, insurance companies, and other traditional financial institutions are excluded due to their involvement in *Riba*.  However, Islamic banks and financial institutions are generally included (after further screening - see below).
   *   **Alcohol:** Companies involved in the production or distribution of alcoholic beverages.
   *   **Tobacco:**  Companies involved in the production or distribution of tobacco products.
   *   **Gambling & Casinos:** Companies operating casinos, lotteries, or involved in gambling activities.
   *   **Pork & Related Products:** Companies involved in the production or processing of pork or related products.
   *   **Military Weapons & Defense:** Companies involved in the production of weapons systems and military hardware (especially those involved in offensive weaponry).  This area can be complex and vary depending on the interpretation.
   *   **Adult Entertainment:** Companies involved in the production or distribution of adult entertainment.

• **Mixed Revenue Companies:** Companies with a mix of Halal and Haram revenue streams are subject to a revenue threshold test. If the proportion of Haram revenue exceeds a predetermined limit (typically 5%), the company is excluded. This threshold is a point of ongoing discussion and refinement within the Sharia advisory community.

1. 1. 1. Stage 3: Financial Ratio Screening

This stage focuses on assessing the financial health of companies based on Sharia principles. Key financial ratios are examined to ensure compliance:

• **Debt-to-Equity Ratio:** Sharia generally discourages excessive leverage. MSCI Islamic Indexes typically impose a maximum debt-to-equity ratio to ensure companies maintain a reasonable level of financial stability. The specific ratio varies based on the index and market. This relates to Fundamental Analysis.
• **Cash & Interest-Bearing Deposits:** The proportion of cash and interest-bearing deposits to total assets is monitored. High levels of interest-bearing assets are viewed unfavorably, as they represent income derived from *Riba*.
• **Receivables-to-Assets Ratio:** High receivables can indicate potential issues with *Gharar* (uncertainty) in transactions.
• **Other Ratios:** Additional ratios may be considered to assess financial stability and compliance with Sharia principles.

1. 1. 1. Stage 4: Islamic Banking/Financial Institution Screening

Islamic banks and financial institutions require a separate, more nuanced screening process. While generally permissible, they must demonstrate adherence to Sharia principles in their operations. This involves evaluating:

• **Sharia Supervisory Board (SSB):** The presence of a reputable and independent SSB is crucial. The SSB’s composition and track record are assessed.
• **Compliance with Sharia Standards:** The institution's adherence to established Sharia standards, such as those issued by the Accounting and Auditing Organization for Islamic Financial Institutions (AAOIFI), is evaluated.
• **Proportion of Non-Compliant Activities:** The proportion of income derived from non-compliant activities (e.g., conventional banking operations) is assessed.

1. 1. 1. Stage 5: Weighting Methodology

Once the eligible universe of Sharia-compliant securities is established, they are weighted within the index. MSCI Islamic Indexes primarily employ a **Free Float-Adjusted Market Capitalization** weighting scheme, similar to their conventional indexes. However, certain adjustments are made:

• **Constituent Weight Limits:** MSCI may impose weight limits on individual constituents to prevent excessive concentration.
• **Index Capping:** Overall index capping may be applied to limit the exposure to specific countries or sectors.
• **Dividend Treatment:** Dividends are generally treated as part of the total return of the index. The treatment of dividends can be complex, particularly if they include interest income.

1. 1. 1. Stage 6: Rebalancing and Reconstitution

MSCI Islamic Indexes are rebalanced and reconstituted periodically (typically quarterly) to reflect changes in the underlying universe and ensure continued Sharia compliance. This process involves:

• **Security Additions and Deletions:** Securities that become Sharia non-compliant are removed from the index, and new compliant securities are added.
• **Weight Adjustments:** Weights are adjusted to reflect changes in market capitalization and other factors.
• **Corporate Actions:** Adjustments are made to account for corporate actions such as mergers, acquisitions, and stock splits.
• **Sharia Supervisory Council Review:** The Sharia Supervisory Council reviews the changes and provides guidance on any compliance-related issues. Technical Analysis of the index composition changes can provide insights.

1. 1. The Role of the Sharia Supervisory Council

A crucial component of the MSCI Islamic Index methodology is the involvement of a Sharia Supervisory Council (SSC). The SSC is comprised of independent Islamic scholars who provide guidance and oversight on all aspects of the index construction and maintenance process. The SSC’s responsibilities include:

• **Defining Sharia Principles:** Establishing and clarifying the Sharia principles that govern the index methodology.
• **Reviewing Screening Criteria:** Reviewing and approving the screening criteria used to identify Sharia-compliant securities.
• **Evaluating New Business Activities:** Assessing the Sharia compliance of new business activities and industries.
• **Resolving Compliance Issues:** Providing guidance on resolving any compliance-related issues that arise.
• **Annual Review of Methodology:** Conducting an annual review of the index methodology to ensure it remains consistent with evolving Sharia interpretations.

1. 1. Challenges and Considerations

Several challenges and considerations are associated with constructing and maintaining MSCI Islamic Indexes:

• **Varying Sharia Interpretations:** Different schools of thought within Islam may have varying interpretations of Sharia principles, leading to potential discrepancies in compliance assessments. MSCI attempts to adopt a consensus-based approach.
• **Data Availability and Accuracy:** Obtaining accurate and reliable data on companies' business activities and financial ratios can be challenging, particularly in emerging markets.
• **Dynamic Business Environments:** Companies' business activities can change over time, requiring ongoing monitoring and reassessment of their Sharia compliance.
• **Complexity of Financial Instruments:** The increasing complexity of financial instruments can make it difficult to assess their Sharia compliance. This requires careful analysis and consultation with the SSC. Consider Derivatives Trading implications.
• **Index Tracking Error:** Maintaining a close tracking error between the index and its underlying constituents can be challenging, especially during periods of market volatility.
• **Liquidity Concerns:** Some Sharia-compliant securities may have limited liquidity, which can impact the index's tradability.

1. 1. MSCI Islamic Index Family

MSCI offers a wide range of Islamic Indexes covering various regions, countries, and asset classes. Some prominent indexes include:

• **MSCI World Islamic Index:** Represents the performance of large and mid-cap Islamic equities globally.
• **MSCI Emerging Markets Islamic Index:** Represents the performance of Islamic equities in emerging markets.
• **MSCI USA Islamic Index:** Represents the performance of Islamic equities in the United States.
• **MSCI Japan Islamic Index:** Represents the performance of Islamic equities in Japan.
• **MSCI Saudi Arabia Islamic Index:** Represents the performance of Islamic equities in Saudi Arabia.
• **MSCI Malaysia Islamic Index:** Represents the performance of Islamic equities in Malaysia.

These indexes are used as benchmarks for a growing number of Islamic investment funds and ETFs. Understanding the methodology behind these indexes is vital for investors seeking to invest in Sharia-compliant assets. See also Portfolio Diversification. For further insights into global market trends, explore Global Economic Outlook. Remember to consider Currency Risk when investing internationally. Learn about Value Investing and Growth Investing strategies. Utilize tools like Moving Averages and Bollinger Bands for technical analysis. Stay informed about Market Sentiment and Trading Psychology. Explore the benefits of Dollar-Cost Averaging and the risks of Overtrading. Understand the impact of Interest Rate Changes and Inflation Rates. Consider using Fibonacci Retracements and Elliott Wave Theory for advanced analysis. Be aware of potential Black Swan Events and practice Position Sizing. Research Candlestick Patterns and Chart Patterns. Learn about Volume Analysis and its role in confirming trends. Stay updated on Regulatory Changes in financial markets. Explore Quantitative Trading strategies. Understand the importance of Due Diligence before investing.

Islamic Finance Sharia Law ESG Investing Fundamental Analysis Risk Management Technical Analysis Portfolio Diversification Global Economic Outlook Currency Risk Value Investing

Start Trading Now

Sign up at IQ Option (Minimum deposit $10) Open an account at Pocket Option (Minimum deposit $5)

Join Our Community

Subscribe to our Telegram channel @strategybin to receive: ✓ Daily trading signals ✓ Exclusive strategy analysis ✓ Market trend alerts ✓ Educational materials for beginners