Investors Intelligence

Investors Intelligence

Investors Intelligence (II) is a widely-followed sentiment indicator in the financial markets, particularly among stock market investors. It provides a contrarian view of market trends by analyzing the opinions of investment newsletters. This article will delve into the history, methodology, interpretation, limitations, and practical applications of Investors Intelligence, geared towards beginners in the world of investing. We will also explore how II can be used in conjunction with other indicators and strategies for a more robust investment approach.

History and Origins

Investors Intelligence was founded in 1965 by Robert Bacon. Bacon, a former editor at the *Wall Street Journal*, noticed a correlation between the bullish-bearish sentiment expressed in investment newsletters and subsequent market movements. He theorized that if a large percentage of newsletter editors were bullish, it was a sign that the market was overbought and due for a correction. Conversely, if a large percentage were bearish, it indicated an oversold market poised for a rally. The core principle behind II is based on the idea that the 'average investor' is often late to the party, buying at market peaks and selling at troughs, driven by emotion rather than rational analysis. Newsletters, representing a more considered (though not infallible) opinion, can therefore serve as a useful gauge of overall investor sentiment. Bacon's initial work laid the foundation for a sentiment indicator that remains relevant today, even in the age of instant information and social media.

Methodology: How Investors Intelligence Works

The Investors Intelligence survey is conducted weekly. The methodology is straightforward: II polls over 100 independent, nationally circulated investment newsletters. These newsletters are asked to provide their outlook on the stock market – whether they are bullish, bearish, or neutral.

**Bullish:** The newsletter editor expects the market to rise.
**Bearish:** The newsletter editor expects the market to fall.
**Neutral:** The newsletter editor anticipates the market will remain relatively unchanged.

II then calculates three key ratios:

1. **Bull Ratio:** The percentage of newsletters that are bullish. 2. **Bear Ratio:** The percentage of newsletters that are bearish. 3. **Ratio Spread (Bull-Bear Spread):** This is the most commonly used metric. It's calculated by subtracting the Bear Ratio from the Bull Ratio. (Bull % - Bear %).

The key to understanding II lies in interpreting these ratios, particularly the Ratio Spread.

Interpreting the Investors Intelligence Data

The interpretation of II data is largely based on contrarian investing principles. Here’s a breakdown:

**High Bull Ratio (typically above 58-60%):** This is considered a bearish signal. A very high percentage of bullish newsletters suggests that most investors are already optimistic, leaving limited room for further upside. The market may be overbought and vulnerable to a correction. It implies excessive optimism and a potential lack of buyers to drive prices higher. Contrarian Investing suggests selling or reducing exposure at this point. This is often related to Euphoria in the market.
**High Bear Ratio (typically above 48-50%):** This is considered a bullish signal. A high percentage of bearish newsletters indicates widespread pessimism, suggesting the market may be oversold and poised for a rebound. It implies a potential buying opportunity as negative sentiment may be overdone. Value Investing principles often align with this signal, looking for undervalued assets during periods of market fear. A large number of bears suggests limited sellers remaining.
**Ratio Spread:**

   *   **Positive and Increasing Spread:** Suggests bullish momentum, but can also indicate an approaching overbought condition. Continued increases should be viewed with caution.
   *   **Negative and Decreasing Spread:** Signals bearish momentum, but can also indicate an approaching oversold condition. Continued decreases should be viewed with caution.
   *   **Spread Crossing Zero:** When the Bull Ratio falls below the Bear Ratio, it's a signal that bearish sentiment is gaining the upper hand.
   *   **Extreme Spreads (both positive and negative):**  These are the most important signals. Extremely high positive spreads suggest a market top is near, while extremely negative spreads suggest a market bottom is near.  These extremes require careful confirmation with other indicators.

It’s crucial to remember that II is *not* a timing tool. It doesn’t predict *when* a correction or rally will happen, only that the *probability* of one increases under certain conditions. It's best used in conjunction with other technical and fundamental analysis techniques.

Historical Performance and Accuracy

Investors Intelligence has a surprisingly good long-term track record. While not perfect, it has accurately predicted many major market turning points over the decades. However, its accuracy can vary depending on market conditions and the specific time period.

**1970s & 1980s:** II was highly accurate during these periods of volatile markets.
**1990s:** The prolonged bull market of the 1990s presented challenges for II, as extreme bullishness became the norm, leading to false signals.
**2000s:** II performed well in predicting the dot-com bubble burst and the subsequent bear market.
**2010s & 2020s:** The prolonged low-interest-rate environment and quantitative easing policies have made interpreting II more complex. The market has often remained irrational for longer periods, delaying the expected corrections.

Despite these challenges, II continues to be a valuable tool for many investors. Backtesting the indicator over different time periods can provide insights into its effectiveness in various market environments. Backtesting is a crucial step in validating any trading strategy.

Limitations of Investors Intelligence

While a useful indicator, Investors Intelligence has limitations that investors must be aware of:

**Lagging Indicator:** II relies on opinions, which are often formed after market movements have already begun. It’s not a leading indicator that predicts future events.
**Subjectivity:** Newsletter editors' opinions are subjective and can be influenced by biases.
**Small Sample Size:** Although the sample size of over 100 newsletters is significant, it’s still a relatively small representation of the entire investment community.
**Changing Market Dynamics:** The financial landscape has changed dramatically since 1965. The rise of algorithmic trading, social media, and other factors may have altered investor behavior and reduced the effectiveness of II.
**False Signals:** II can generate false signals, especially during periods of prolonged market trends.
**Not a Standalone System:** Relying solely on II for investment decisions is risky. It should be used in conjunction with other indicators and analysis techniques.
**Influence of Media:** Newsletter opinions can be influenced by mainstream media narratives, potentially creating a feedback loop.
**Cost of Subscription:** Access to the full Investors Intelligence data requires a subscription. However, many financial websites and services provide summaries of the data.

Using Investors Intelligence with Other Indicators

To overcome the limitations of II, it’s best to combine it with other indicators and strategies. Here are some examples:

**Moving Averages:** Moving Averages can help confirm the signals generated by II. For example, if II is signaling a potential correction and the price is below its 50-day moving average, it strengthens the bearish case.
**Relative Strength Index (RSI):** RSI is an oscillator that measures the magnitude of recent price changes to evaluate overbought or oversold conditions. Combining II with RSI can provide a more accurate assessment of market sentiment. A high Bull Ratio combined with an overbought RSI reading suggests a higher probability of a correction.
**MACD (Moving Average Convergence Divergence):** MACD helps identify changes in the strength, direction, momentum and duration of a trend in a stock’s price. Divergence between the MACD and price can confirm signals from II.
**Volatility Index (VIX):** VIX measures market expectations of volatility. A spike in VIX, combined with a high Bear Ratio, can indicate a potential buying opportunity.
**On-Balance Volume (OBV):** OBV uses volume flow to predict price changes. Confirming II signals with OBV can add another layer of analysis.
**Fibonacci Retracements:** Fibonacci Retracements can help identify potential support and resistance levels, providing entry and exit points based on II signals.
**Elliott Wave Theory:** Elliott Wave Theory attempts to identify recurring wave patterns in financial markets. Combining II with Elliott Wave analysis can provide a broader context for market movements.
**Volume Analysis:** Volume is a crucial element in confirming price trends. High volume during a rally confirmed by a low Bear Ratio strengthens the bullish signal.
**Trend Lines:** Trend Lines help visualize support and resistance levels. Breaking trend lines combined with II signals can indicate a change in market direction.
**Candlestick Patterns:** Candlestick Patterns offer visual clues about market sentiment. Bearish engulfing patterns coinciding with a high Bull Ratio strengthen the bearish signal.
**Put/Call Ratio:** The Put/Call Ratio measures the relative volume of put options (bets that the price will fall) to call options (bets that the price will rise). A high Put/Call Ratio can confirm bearish signals from II.
**Advance/Decline Line:** The Advance/Decline Line shows the cumulative difference between the number of advancing stocks and declining stocks. Divergence between the Advance/Decline Line and the market index can signal a potential trend reversal, reinforced by II data.
**Sector Rotation:** Sector Rotation involves shifting investments between different sectors of the economy based on the business cycle. II can help identify when to rotate out of overvalued sectors (high Bull Ratio) and into undervalued sectors (high Bear Ratio).
**Intermarket Analysis:** Intermarket Analysis examines the relationships between different asset classes (e.g., stocks, bonds, commodities). Analyzing these relationships alongside II can provide a more comprehensive view of market conditions.
**Confirmation with Economic Data:** Correlating II signals with economic indicators (e.g., GDP growth, inflation, unemployment) can provide further insight into the market’s direction.
**Sentiment Analysis of Social Media:** While more challenging, analyzing sentiment on platforms like Twitter and Reddit can provide a broader gauge of investor sentiment, complementing the data from investment newsletters. Social Media Sentiment Analysis is an emerging field.
**Commitment of Traders (COT) Report:** The COT Report provides information about the positions held by different groups of traders in futures markets. Analyzing the COT report alongside II can offer valuable insights into institutional investor behavior.
**Ichimoku Cloud:** Ichimoku Cloud is a comprehensive technical analysis system that identifies support and resistance levels, trend direction, and momentum. Using the Ichimoku Cloud in conjunction with II can provide a more nuanced understanding of market conditions.
**Bollinger Bands:** Bollinger Bands measure market volatility and identify potential overbought or oversold conditions. Combining Bollinger Bands with II can provide a more accurate assessment of market sentiment.
**Chart Patterns:** Recognizing classic Chart Patterns like head and shoulders, double tops/bottoms, and triangles can help confirm signals from II.
**Gann Angles:** Gann Angles are trendlines based on geometric relationships that Gann believed could predict price movements. Using Gann Angles in conjunction with II can provide additional support and resistance levels.
**Harmonic Patterns:** Harmonic Patterns are specific price patterns based on Fibonacci ratios that can predict potential reversal or continuation points. Combining Harmonic Patterns with II can increase the probability of successful trades.
**Wyckoff Accumulation/Distribution:** Wyckoff Method is a technical analysis approach that focuses on understanding the phases of accumulation and distribution in financial markets. Applying the Wyckoff Method alongside II can provide insights into the underlying market structure.

Conclusion

Investors Intelligence is a valuable sentiment indicator that can provide contrarian investors with a unique perspective on market trends. However, it’s crucial to understand its limitations and use it in conjunction with other indicators and analysis techniques. By combining II with technical analysis, fundamental analysis, and a disciplined trading approach, investors can increase their chances of success in the financial markets. Remember, no indicator is foolproof, and risk management is paramount. Risk Management is key to long-term investing success.

Start Trading Now

Sign up at IQ Option (Minimum deposit $10) Open an account at Pocket Option (Minimum deposit $5)

Join Our Community

Subscribe to our Telegram channel @strategybin to receive: ✓ Daily trading signals ✓ Exclusive strategy analysis ✓ Market trend alerts ✓ Educational materials for beginners