Articles of Confederation

Articles of Confederation

The Articles of Confederation were the first governing document of the United States, adopted by the Continental Congress in 1777 and ratified by all thirteen states in 1781. It represented the first attempt to establish a unified national government after declaring independence from Great Britain during the American Revolutionary War. While a crucial stepping stone in the formation of the nation, the Articles ultimately proved inadequate and were replaced by the current United States Constitution in 1789. Understanding the Articles of Confederation is vital for comprehending the historical context of the Constitution and the ongoing debates about the balance of power between the federal government and the states. This article will explore the origins, structure, powers, weaknesses, and eventual demise of this foundational, yet flawed, governmental system.

Origins and Context

The impetus for the Articles of Confederation arose directly from the experience of the colonies under British rule. Colonists deeply resented the centralized authority and perceived abuses of power exercised by the British Crown and Parliament. They feared replicating this model in their new nation. Consequently, when considering a new form of government, the prevailing sentiment strongly favored a confederation – a “league of friendship” among independent states, where the states retained significant autonomy and the central government possessed limited powers.

The Second Continental Congress, functioning as the nation’s government during the Revolutionary War, began discussing the need for a formal union in 1776. A committee chaired by John Dickinson drafted the first version of the Articles in July 1776. However, debates over issues like western land claims held by various states delayed ratification for several years. These land claims, particularly those of states like Virginia, Massachusetts, Connecticut, and the Carolinas, were a significant sticking point. States claiming vast territories west of the Appalachian Mountains resisted ceding these lands to the national government, fearing a loss of power and potential revenue.

Ultimately, in 1780 and 1781, states began to ratify the Articles after several states – notably Virginia – relinquished their western land claims to the national government. This concession was crucial in securing the support of landless states like Maryland, which had previously refused to ratify without assurances that western lands would be available for settlement by all citizens. The Articles officially went into effect on March 1, 1781, marking the establishment of the first national government of the United States.

Structure of the Government under the Articles

The government established by the Articles of Confederation was deliberately weak and decentralized. It featured a unicameral (one-house) legislature called the Congress of the Confederation. Each state had one vote in Congress, regardless of its population size. This was a direct response to the colonial experience of being represented proportionally to population in the British Parliament, where larger colonies often dominated decision-making.

There was no separate executive branch or national judiciary under the Articles. Executive functions were handled by committees of Congress, making decision-making slow and cumbersome. The absence of a national judiciary meant there was no national court system to resolve disputes between states or interpret national laws.

The key structural components were:

**Congress:** The sole branch of the national government, responsible for making laws, declaring war, negotiating treaties, and managing relations with foreign nations.
**Committees:** Congress relied on committees to carry out executive functions, such as conducting foreign affairs and managing finances.
**State Governments:** Retained significant sovereignty and authority, including the power to levy taxes, regulate commerce within their borders, and maintain their own militias.
**Articles of Confederation document itself:** The foundational document outlining the powers and limitations of the national government.

Powers Granted to the National Government

The Articles of Confederation granted limited, specific powers to the national government. These powers were primarily focused on matters of common defense, foreign affairs, and interstate relations. Key powers included:

**Declaring War:** Congress had the sole authority to declare war and raise and equip armies. This power was essential for defending the new nation from external threats.
**Foreign Affairs:** Congress could negotiate and enter into treaties with foreign nations, conduct diplomacy, and manage relations with other countries.
**Coining Money:** Congress had the power to coin money and establish a national currency, although this power was rarely effectively exercised.
**Post Office:** Congress established a national postal system to facilitate communication and commerce among the states.
**Native American Affairs:** Congress had the authority to negotiate treaties with Native American tribes and manage relations with them.
**Resolving Disputes Between States:** Congress served as a forum for resolving disputes and conflicts between the states, though its ability to enforce resolutions was limited.
**Western Land Policy:** The Articles authorized Congress to survey, divide, and sell the lands west of the Appalachian Mountains, leading to the passage of the Northwest Ordinance in 1787, a significant achievement of the Confederation government. This ordinance established a process for admitting new states to the Union and prohibited slavery in the Northwest Territory.

Weaknesses of the Articles of Confederation

Despite its initial successes, the Articles of Confederation suffered from numerous fundamental weaknesses that ultimately led to its failure. These weaknesses stemmed from the deliberate attempt to create a weak central government and preserve state sovereignty.

**Lack of Power to Tax:** The most significant weakness of the Articles was the national government's inability to directly tax the states or their citizens. It could only request funds from the states, which were often unwilling or unable to contribute. This chronic financial instability hampered the government's ability to pay its debts, fund essential services, and maintain a strong military. This is analogous to a trading strategy lacking sufficient capital – it's destined to fail.
**No National Currency:** The lack of a uniform national currency created economic chaos and hindered interstate trade. Each state could issue its own currency, leading to fluctuating exchange rates and confusion. This is similar to a volatile market without standardized instruments.
**Regulation of Commerce:** Congress lacked the power to regulate interstate commerce. States imposed tariffs and trade barriers on goods from other states, hindering economic growth and creating internal conflicts. This is comparable to a market lacking liquidity and efficient price discovery.
**Unanimous Consent for Amendments:** Amending the Articles required unanimous consent from all thirteen states, making it virtually impossible to adapt the government to changing circumstances. This rigid structure prevented necessary reforms. It’s like a trading system with no parameters for optimization.
**Weak Central Authority:** The absence of a strong executive branch and national judiciary made it difficult to enforce laws, resolve disputes, and provide effective leadership. The lack of a centralized authority created a power vacuum and hampered the government’s ability to respond to crises. This is akin to a trading strategy without risk management.
**State Sovereignty:** While intended to protect liberty, the emphasis on state sovereignty led to disunity and a lack of national cohesion. States often acted in their own self-interest, disregarding the needs of the nation as a whole. This is comparable to a portfolio lacking diversification.
**Difficulty Raising an Army:** Congress struggled to raise and maintain a national army, relying on state militias, which were often poorly trained and unreliable. This weakness left the new nation vulnerable to external threats and internal unrest. Think of it as attempting a high-risk trade without proper position sizing.
**No National Economic Policy:** Without the power to regulate commerce or establish a national currency, Congress could not implement a coherent national economic policy. This led to economic instability and hindered the development of a unified national market. This is similar to a trading strategy ignoring fundamental analysis.

Shay's Rebellion and the Call for Change

The weaknesses of the Articles of Confederation became painfully evident during **Shays’ Rebellion** (1786-1787) in Massachusetts. This uprising, led by Revolutionary War veteran Daniel Shays, was sparked by economic hardship and high taxes imposed on farmers. The Massachusetts government, lacking the resources to effectively suppress the rebellion, appealed to the national government for assistance. However, Congress was unable to raise a sufficient army to intervene.

Shays’ Rebellion exposed the fundamental flaws of the Articles of Confederation and demonstrated the urgent need for a stronger national government. The inability of the national government to maintain order and protect property rights alarmed many leading Americans, including George Washington, James Madison, and Alexander Hamilton. They argued that a more centralized government with the power to tax, regulate commerce, and enforce laws was essential for the survival of the new nation. This event served as a critical catalyst for the movement to revise the Articles. It's a prime example of a "black swan" event highlighting systemic risk.

The Constitutional Convention and the Replacement of the Articles

In February 1787, the Continental Congress authorized a convention in Philadelphia to revise the Articles of Confederation. However, the delegates quickly realized that the Articles were fundamentally flawed and could not be effectively amended. Instead, they decided to draft an entirely new governing document – the United States Constitution.

The **Constitutional Convention** (May-September 1787) was a landmark event in American history. Delegates from twelve states (Rhode Island refused to participate) debated and compromised on a range of issues, including the structure of the government, the division of powers, and the representation of states and citizens.

The Constitution created a federal system of government, dividing power between a national government and state governments. It established three separate branches of government – legislative, executive, and judicial – with a system of checks and balances to prevent any one branch from becoming too powerful. The Constitution also granted the national government the power to tax, regulate commerce, and enforce laws.

The Constitution was ratified by the states in 1788 and went into effect in 1789, effectively replacing the Articles of Confederation. The transition from the Articles to the Constitution marked a significant shift in American governance, from a weak confederation of independent states to a more unified and powerful nation. The new system, while still debated and refined, provided a more stable and effective framework for governing the United States.

Legacy of the Articles of Confederation

While ultimately unsuccessful as a long-term governing document, the Articles of Confederation played a crucial role in the early development of the United States. It provided a framework for governing the nation during the Revolutionary War and established important precedents for the future. Its successes included:

**Negotiating the Treaty of Paris (1783):** The Articles government successfully negotiated the Treaty of Paris, officially ending the Revolutionary War and securing American independence.
**Northwest Ordinance of 1787:** This landmark legislation established a process for admitting new states to the Union and prohibited slavery in the Northwest Territory.
**Managing Western Lands:** The Articles government effectively managed the vast territories west of the Appalachian Mountains.

However, the failures of the Articles served as valuable lessons for the framers of the Constitution. They recognized the need for a stronger national government with the power to address national challenges and promote the common good. The experience with the Articles helped shape the structure and principles of the Constitution, ensuring a more stable and enduring union. The lessons learned from the Articles regarding central banking, fiscal policy, and trade regulation continue to inform economic policy debates today. Understanding the Articles is akin to understanding the historical volatility of an asset – it provides context for future price action. The Articles represented a period of high risk and uncertainty, eventually leading to a more stable and predictable system.

Furthermore, the debates surrounding the Articles laid the groundwork for ongoing discussions about federalism – the balance of power between the national government and the states – a central theme in American political thought. The Articles also contributed to the development of American political culture, emphasizing principles of limited government, individual liberty, and popular sovereignty.

Resources for Further Study

Trading Related Concepts

Here are some concepts that can be related to the Articles of Confederation:

**Risk Management:** The Articles lacked risk management, ultimately leading to its downfall. (Analogy to trading)
**Volatility:** The economic instability under the Articles reflects high market volatility.
**Liquidity:** The lack of a national currency resulted in low liquidity in the market.
**Diversification:** The states acting independently lacked diversification, making them vulnerable.
**Fundamental Analysis:** The Articles neglected fundamental economic policies.
**Technical Analysis:** Observing the weaknesses of the Articles is like performing technical analysis on a failing system.
**Trend Following:** The trend towards a stronger central government was evident in the aftermath of Shays' Rebellion.
**Moving Averages:** The Articles represented a failing trend, requiring a new system (Constitution).
**Support and Resistance Levels:** The states represented resistance to a strong central authority.
**Breakout:** The Constitutional Convention represented a breakout from the limitations of the Articles.
**Fibonacci Retracement:** Analyzing the historical context helps understand the "retracement" of initial ideals.
**Bollinger Bands:** Economic instability under the Articles could be visualized using Bollinger Bands.
**MACD (Moving Average Convergence Divergence):** The shift towards a new system (Constitution) can be seen as a MACD crossover.
**RSI (Relative Strength Index):** The Articles' weakening position could be reflected in a declining RSI.
**Stochastic Oscillator:** The Articles' probability of failure increased as the stochastic oscillator reached oversold levels.
**Ichimoku Cloud:** The Articles’ position within the Ichimoku Cloud indicated a bearish outlook.
**Elliott Wave Theory:** The transition from Articles to Constitution can be viewed as a wave pattern.
**Candlestick Patterns:** Analyzing historical events reveals bearish candlestick patterns for the Articles.
**Volume Analysis:** The growing support for a new Constitution reflected increased volume.
**Correlation Analysis:** The states' lack of coordination reflected negative correlation.
**Time Series Analysis:** The Articles’ performance over time showed a declining trend.
**Monte Carlo Simulation:** Simulating different scenarios highlights the risks of a weak central government.
**Value Investing:** The Constitution represented a “value investment” in a stronger nation.
**Growth Investing:** The potential for economic growth under the Constitution was a key driver.
**Options Trading:** The Articles represented a “put option” – a bet against a strong central government.
**Futures Contracts:** The promise of a stable future was like a futures contract.
**Arbitrage Opportunities:** The lack of a unified currency created arbitrage opportunities.

Start Trading Now

Sign up at IQ Option (Minimum deposit $10) Open an account at Pocket Option (Minimum deposit $5)

Join Our Community

Subscribe to our Telegram channel @strategybin to receive: ✓ Daily trading signals ✓ Exclusive strategy analysis ✓ Market trend alerts ✓ Educational materials for beginners