Calculating Profit Potential with In The Money Options

This article focuses exclusively on understanding and calculating the profit potential associated with In-the-money Binary option contracts. While the core concept of a binary option is simple—predicting if the price will be above or below a set strike price at Expiry time—understanding how profit is realized, especially when the prediction is correct, is crucial for setting realistic expectations.

Foundations of Binary Option Profitability

A Binary option offers a fixed payout if the trade settles correctly (in-the-money) and typically results in the loss of the initial investment if it settles incorrectly (out-of-the-money). Unlike traditional options or spot trading, where profit varies based on the distance the price moves past the strike, binary options offer a predetermined return rate.

In-the-Money Versus Out-of-the-Money

The relationship between the asset's final price and the strike price determines the outcome.

A Call option finishes **in-the-money** if the final price is strictly *above* the strike price at expiry.
A Put option finishes **in-the-money** if the final price is strictly *below* the strike price at expiry.

If the price lands exactly on the strike price, this is often referred to as "at-the-money" or "touching the strike," and typically results in the return of the original investment, though specific broker rules must be checked.

If the contract is **out-of-the-money**, the trader loses the entire amount invested in that specific trade.

The Role of Payout Percentage

The profit potential in a binary option is directly tied to the **Payout** percentage offered by the broker for that specific asset and Expiry time. This percentage is applied only to the invested capital if the option expires in-the-money.

For example, if a broker offers an 85% payout on a trade, and you invest $100, the total return if you win is $100 (your initial investment returned) + $85 (your profit).

Scenario	Investment	Payout Rate	Profit if ITM	Total Return if ITM
Scenario A	$100	80%	$80	$180
Scenario B	$50	92%	$46	$96

This fixed return structure is what differentiates binary options from instruments like spot trading, where profits fluctuate based on price movement.

Calculating Potential Gross Profit

Calculating the potential profit is straightforward once you know your investment amount and the offered payout rate. This calculation determines your *gross* profit, meaning the profit before accounting for any losses on other trades.

Step 1: Determine the Investment Amount This is the capital you allocate to the specific Binary option contract. This is a key component of Position sizing.

Step 2: Identify the Broker's Payout Percentage This rate is displayed before you execute the trade and varies based on market conditions, the underlying asset (e.g., EUR/USD, Gold), and the Expiry time. Higher volatility or less popular assets might offer lower payouts.

Step 3: Calculate the Profit Amount Multiply the Investment Amount by the Payout Percentage (expressed as a decimal).

Formula: Profit = Investment Amount * Payout Percentage (as decimal)

Step 4: Calculate the Total Return Add the calculated Profit Amount to the original Investment Amount.

Formula: Total Return = Investment Amount + Profit Amount

Example Calculation: Suppose you decide to invest $200 on an EUR/USD Call option with a 15-minute Expiry time, and the broker is offering a 78% payout.

Investment: $200
Payout Rate: 78% or 0.78

Profit Calculation: $200 * 0.78 = $156 Total Return Calculation: $200 + $156 = $356

If the price is above the strike price at expiry, you receive $356 back. If it is out-of-the-money, you lose the initial $200.

Entry and Exit Mechanics Related to Profit Calculation

In binary options, the entry price (the strike price) and the exit price (the price at expiry) are determined automatically by the market, not manually by the trader after entry, unlike many other financial instruments.

Entry Phase: Setting the Stake and Assessing Risk

Before entering the trade, the trader must decide on the stake and ensure the potential profit aligns with their Risk management goals.

Analyze the Market: Use technical analysis tools, such as Candlestick pattern recognition, Support and resistance levels, or indicators like RSI or MACD, to form a high-probability prediction (e.g., predicting a rise in price).
Select Asset and Expiry: Choose the underlying asset and the appropriate Expiry time.
Determine Stake: Decide how much capital to risk, keeping in mind the principles of Setting Effective Daily Loss Limits for Binary Options.
Verify Payout: Note the displayed payout percentage. This defines the maximum profit for that specific trade size.
Execute Trade: Select Call or Put based on the prediction.

Exit Phase: The In-the-Money Settlement

The exit is passive; the contract automatically settles at the predetermined expiry time.

Market Movement: The price of the underlying asset moves during the contract duration.
Settlement Trigger: At the exact moment of expiry, the broker compares the final price to the strike price.
Profit Realization (ITM): If the condition for the option type is met (e.g., price > strike for a Call), the system credits the account with the Investment Amount plus the calculated Profit Amount. For example, if you won $80 on a $100 trade, your account balance increases by $80.
Loss Realization (OTM): If the condition is not met, the system debits the account by the full Investment Amount.

It is important to note that while you are aiming for an in-the-money finish, the *magnitude* of the price move past the strike price does not increase your profit beyond the stated payout percentage. A $0.0001 move past the strike yields the same profit as a $1.00 move past the strike, provided both settle ITM.

Setting Realistic Expectations for Profit Potential

New traders often overestimate the consistency of high returns. Calculating profit potential must be balanced with the reality of win rates and Risk management.

The Necessary Win Rate for Profitability

Because binary options involve risking 100% of the investment for a potential return less than 100% (e.g., risking $100 to win $80), you need a win rate significantly above 50% just to break even over time.

To achieve break-even (where Total Profit = Total Loss), the required win rate (WR) can be calculated based on the average payout (P). If the payout is 80% (P=0.80), you lose 100% when you lose.

Required Break-Even Win Rate (WR) = 1 / (1 + P)

Using the 80% Payout Example: WR = 1 / (1 + 0.80) WR = 1 / 1.80 WR ≈ 0.5556 or 55.56%

This means that if you consistently achieve an 80% payout, you must win at least 55.56% of your trades just to avoid losing money overall. If your strategy only yields a 52% win rate, you will lose money despite winning more trades than you lose, due to the asymmetry of risk versus reward inherent in many binary option structures.

This highlights why consistently finding high-payout trades (e.g., 90%+) or developing a strategy with a much higher win rate (e.g., 60%+) is necessary for generating actual profit beyond covering losses.

Impact of Volatility and Asset Class

Profit potential, as defined by the payout percentage, changes dynamically.

High Volatility Markets: During major news events, brokers might lower payouts because the risk of a large price swing makes the outcome less predictable, or they might temporarily suspend trading.
Low Volatility Markets: Sideways or quiet markets often feature lower payouts because the probability of hitting the strike price is higher, reducing the broker's risk margin.
Asset Class: Currency pairs (Forex) often have different payout structures than indices or commodities. Always check the current quote for the specific asset you are trading, as detailed in Understanding Binary Option Asset Classes and Quotes.

Practical Checklist for Maximizing ITM Outcomes

While the calculation of profit is fixed post-trade, maximizing the *probability* of achieving an in-the-money outcome requires disciplined application of analysis and risk control.

Strategy Confirmation: Does the setup align with your tested strategy (e.g., a strong Trend confirmation combined with an Elliott wave count)?
Indicator Validation: If using indicators like Bollinger Bands, ensure multiple signals confirm the direction before entering.
Time Alignment: Does the chosen Expiry time give the market enough time to move to your predicted level without running into known resistance or support zones that might reverse the price?
Risk Allocation: Is the invested amount small enough that a string of losses will not impact your ability to trade tomorrow? (Refer to The Role of Emotional Discipline in Binary Option Trading).
Journaling: Record the expected profit and the actual outcome in your Trading journal. This is essential for tracking your true performance, as detailed in How to Keep a Trading Journal in Binary Options Trading.

Simple Backtesting Idea for Profit Potential Validation

Before risking real capital, you must validate that your strategy, combined with the broker's typical payout structure, is profitable.

Data Collection: Pull historical price data for your chosen asset (e.g., the last 100 trading sessions for EUR/USD).
Hypothetical Entry: For each session, identify 10 clear trading setups based on your chosen analysis method (e.g., a specific Candlestick pattern at a major Support and resistance level).
Simulate Expiry: Assume a fixed, realistic Expiry time (e.g., 5 minutes). Determine if the price at that exact future time would have been ITM or OTM.
Apply Payout: For every simulated win, calculate the profit using a *conservative* average payout rate (e.g., 75%). For every loss, record a 100% loss of stake.
Analyze Net Result: Sum up the total hypothetical profits and losses. If the net result is positive, the strategy has the potential to generate profit based on the assumed payout structure.

If you are testing on a demo account provided by a broker like IQ Option or Pocket Option, use the demo funds to execute these backtests in real-time, paying close attention to the displayed payout rates for the specific timeframes you are testing. Remember that broker interfaces allow quick selection of stakes and expiry, streamlining this process.

Common Mistakes Related to Profit Calculation

Mistakes often occur when traders confuse gross return with net profit or fail to account for the required win rate.

Mistake 1: Assuming 50% win rate is profitable. If your average payout is 85%, winning 50% of the time means you are losing money because you need 54% wins just to break even (1 / 1.85 ≈ 54%).
Mistake 2: Focusing only on the high payout. A 95% payout is excellent, but if your strategy only wins 40% of the time, the high payout will not save you from significant losses. Risk management dictates that the strategy's edge (win rate) is more important than the payout rate in the long run.
Mistake 3: Ignoring fees or commissions (though rare in standard binary options, some brokers might have withdrawal fees). Always confirm the exact amount returned upon a successful trade.
Mistake 4: Trading based on market noise rather than clear setups. Trading without a defined system leads to random outcomes, making consistent ITM settlement impossible to predict or calculate potential profit for accurately. Traders should review resources like Navigating Binary Options: How to Find the Best Broker for Beginners to ensure they are using a platform that clearly displays these crucial payout figures.

Summary of Profit Realization

The profit potential in a Binary option is entirely defined *before* the trade is placed, determined by the broker's offered payout percentage applied to the invested capital, contingent on the contract settling In-the-money. The trader's job is not to calculate how *much* the price moves, but to correctly predict the *direction* relative to the strike price at the specified Expiry time. Successful trading requires a strategy that consistently achieves a win rate high enough to overcome the structural break-even point dictated by the payout percentage.

Recommended Binary Options Platforms

Platform	Why beginners choose it	Register / Offer
IQ Option	Simple interface, popular asset list, quick order entry	IQ Option Registration
Pocket Option	Fast execution, tournaments, multiple expiration choices	Pocket Option Registration

Join Our Community

Subscribe to our Telegram channel @copytradingall for analytics, free signals, and much more!

Calculating Profit Potential with in the Money Options

Contents