Alexander Elder

Alexander Elder

Alexander Elder (born July 29, 1931) is a Russian-American physician, psychiatrist, and trading coach. He is widely recognized as a leading authority on trading psychology and the development of systematic trading strategies. Elder's work emphasizes the crucial role of psychology in successful trading, arguing that mastering one’s emotions is as important – if not more so – than mastering technical analysis. He is the author of several influential books, most notably *Trading for a Living* (1993), which has become a cornerstone text for many traders. This article provides a comprehensive overview of Alexander Elder’s life, work, trading philosophy, and key concepts.

Biography

Born in Romania to Russian parents who fled the Bolshevik Revolution, Elder experienced a turbulent childhood marked by displacement and hardship. His family eventually immigrated to the United States in 1940. He earned his M.D. from New York University and subsequently worked as a psychiatrist. His medical background profoundly influenced his approach to trading, leading him to view the market as a living organism with its own "personality" and psychological states.

Elder began trading in the 1950s, initially focusing on stocks. Over the years, he traded a variety of markets, including stocks, commodities, and currencies. His experiences, both successful and unsuccessful, formed the basis of his trading philosophy. He spent decades refining his strategies and, crucially, understanding the psychological traps that lead traders to failure. He retired from practicing medicine to devote himself full-time to trading education and coaching in the 1990s. He continues to lecture and write on trading psychology and systems.

Trading Philosophy: The Three Disciplines

Elder’s trading philosophy is structured around what he calls the "Three Disciplines" – a holistic approach to trading that encompasses belief systems, risk management, and trading systems. These three disciplines are interconnected and must be developed simultaneously for consistent profitability.

Belief Systems: This discipline focuses on the trader's psychological makeup. Elder argues that successful traders must have a winning belief system, characterized by self-acceptance, discipline, and a realistic understanding of risk. Common detrimental beliefs include the gambler’s fallacy, overconfidence, and the belief that one can “beat the market.” Developing a positive and rational belief system is the foundation of successful trading. This is closely related to concepts like cognitive biases and the importance of emotional control.

Risk Management: Elder considers risk management the most crucial discipline. He advocates for a conservative approach to position sizing, limiting risk to a small percentage (typically 2%) of trading capital on any single trade. This prevents catastrophic losses and allows traders to survive inevitable losing streaks. He emphasizes the importance of using stop-loss orders to protect capital and the concept of Kelly criterion (though he doesn't explicitly advocate for full Kelly, recommending a fraction of it for practical application). Understanding drawdown and its impact on psychology is also paramount. He stresses the need to trade small and let profits grow.

Trading Systems: This discipline involves developing a mechanical system for identifying and executing trades. Elder’s systems are based on price action and volume analysis, incorporating techniques such as Fibonacci retracements, Elliott Wave Theory, and moving averages. Crucially, the system should be objective and eliminate as much discretionary decision-making as possible. The system provides the *what* of trading, while the disciplines provide the *how* and *why*. This links directly to the importance of backtesting and forward testing.

Key Concepts and Tools

Elder developed several specific tools and concepts that are central to his trading approach.

Multiple Time Frame Analysis: Elder strongly advocates analyzing markets on multiple time frames. This provides a broader perspective and helps traders identify the dominant trend and potential turning points. He suggests using a three-time-frame approach – a long-term frame to identify the primary trend, an intermediate frame to refine entry points, and a short-term frame to time entries and exits. This relates to the concept of market structure.

Force Index: This is Elder's proprietary indicator, designed to measure the strength of a trend. It combines price and volume to identify divergences between price action and underlying buying or selling pressure. A rising Force Index confirms an uptrend, while a falling Force Index confirms a downtrend. Divergences between the Force Index and price can signal potential trend reversals. Understanding volume analysis is crucial for interpreting the Force Index.

Elder-Ray: This indicator is a variation of the moving average, designed to smooth price data and identify trend direction. It uses a weighted average that gives greater weight to recent price data. Elder-Ray is used in conjunction with other indicators, such as the Force Index, to confirm trend direction and identify potential trading opportunities. It’s related to other smoothing techniques like Exponential Moving Averages.

Market Profile: Though not invented by Elder, he extensively uses the Market Profile concept to understand market behavior and identify areas of value and support/resistance. The Market Profile visually represents the distribution of price over time, revealing important information about market acceptance and rejection levels. This ties into understanding order flow and point and figure charting.

Three Push Play: A pattern Elder identifies that suggests a trend reversal. It occurs when price makes three attempts to break through a resistance level (in an uptrend) or support level (in a downtrend) and fails, indicating a weakening of the trend. It’s a form of candlestick pattern recognition.

Impulse and Correction: Elder emphasizes the cyclical nature of markets, characterized by alternating periods of impulse (trending moves) and correction (consolidation periods). Traders should identify the current phase of the market cycle and adjust their strategies accordingly. This concept is central to wave theory.

Psychological Levels: Elder highlights the importance of psychological levels, such as round numbers (e.g., $100, $50) and previous highs and lows, as potential areas of support and resistance. These levels often attract trading activity and can influence price movements. Understanding support and resistance is fundamental.

Trading Plan: Elder stresses the importance of having a detailed trading plan that outlines entry and exit rules, risk management parameters, and psychological guidelines. The plan should be followed consistently, regardless of emotional impulses. This is a core aspect of systematic trading.

The Psychology of Trading

Perhaps Elder’s most significant contribution to the field of trading is his emphasis on the psychological aspects of trading. He identifies several common psychological traps that lead traders to failure, including:

The Illusion of Control: The belief that one can predict the market with certainty.
The Gambler’s Fallacy: The belief that past events influence future outcomes in a random process.
Overconfidence: An exaggerated belief in one’s own abilities.
Fear and Greed: These emotions can cloud judgment and lead to impulsive decisions.
Revenge Trading: Attempting to recoup losses by taking irrational risks.

Elder's work provides strategies for overcoming these psychological biases, such as practicing self-awareness, developing a disciplined mindset, and accepting losses as a part of the trading process. He advocates for maintaining a trading journal to track trades, identify patterns of behavior, and learn from mistakes. The importance of mindfulness and meditation in trading is often discussed in relation to Elder’s work.

Criticisms and Considerations

While Alexander Elder’s work is widely respected, it is not without its critics. Some argue that his indicators, such as the Force Index and Elder-Ray, are lagging indicators and may not provide timely signals. Others criticize his emphasis on psychology, arguing that it is difficult to quantify and apply consistently.

It's also important to note that Elder’s trading style is generally considered discretionary, even though he advocates for systematic rules. Interpreting his indicators and applying his concepts often requires subjective judgment. Furthermore, his strategies may not be suitable for all markets or trading styles. Algorithmic trading and fully automated systems offer a contrasting approach.

Despite these criticisms, Elder’s work remains highly influential and provides valuable insights into the complexities of trading. His emphasis on risk management, psychology, and multiple time frame analysis continues to resonate with traders of all levels. He encourages continuous learning and adaptation, recognizing that the markets are constantly evolving. Understanding market efficiency and its implications is also crucial when evaluating Elder’s strategies.

Start Trading Now

Sign up at IQ Option (Minimum deposit $10) Open an account at Pocket Option (Minimum deposit $5)

Join Our Community

Subscribe to our Telegram channel @strategybin to receive: ✓ Daily trading signals ✓ Exclusive strategy analysis ✓ Market trend alerts ✓ Educational materials for beginners