Jobs to Be Done Framework

1. Jobs to Be Done (JTBD) Framework

The Jobs to Be Done (JTBD) framework is a powerful tool for understanding customer motivation and driving innovation. Unlike traditional segmentation approaches that focus on *who* the customer is (demographics, psychographics), JTBD focuses on *why* the customer chooses a product or service. It posits that customers aren't simply buying products; they are "hiring" them to do a job. This article will provide a comprehensive overview of the JTBD framework, its origins, core concepts, practical application, and how it differs from other marketing and product development methodologies.

Origins and Key Figures

The JTBD framework was pioneered by Clayton M. Christensen, Harvard Business School professor and author of *The Innovator's Dilemma* and *Competing Against Luck*. Christensen initially developed the framework through research into why successful companies often failed to sustain their success when faced with disruptive innovation. He noticed that established companies, focused on satisfying their existing customers, often missed opportunities to address unmet "jobs" that were emerging in the market. His work, along with contributions from Bob Moesta and Greg Bernarda, formalized the JTBD principles. The core insight was that understanding the underlying “job” a customer is trying to accomplish is more valuable than understanding the customer’s attributes. This led to the development of a methodology to uncover these jobs and build products specifically to address them. Market Research is a crucial component of understanding these underlying motivations.

Core Concepts: The "Job"

At the heart of the JTBD framework lies the concept of the "job." A job isn't simply a task; it’s a fundamental progress a customer is trying to make in their life. It’s the root cause of why someone seeks a solution. This progress can be functional, social, or emotional.

• **Functional Jobs:** These relate to the practical task a customer is trying to accomplish. For example, the functional job of a drill is to make a hole.
• **Social Jobs:** These relate to how the customer wants to be perceived by others. For example, the social job of owning a luxury car might be to signal status and success.
• **Emotional Jobs:** These relate to how the customer wants to *feel*. For example, the emotional job of drinking coffee might be to feel alert and energized.

Crucially, a single product can address multiple jobs, and a single job can be addressed by multiple products. A smartphone, for instance, addresses functional jobs (communication, information access), social jobs (staying connected, expressing identity), and emotional jobs (feeling secure, being entertained). Understanding the *hierarchy* of these jobs is critical. Often, the emotional and social jobs are more powerful drivers of behavior than the functional jobs.

The Forces of Progress

Christensen identified four forces that influence a customer's decision to "hire" a product to do a job:

1. **Push of the Situation:** What is the current negative situation the customer is trying to escape? This is the pain point that motivates the search for a solution. Problem Identification is key here. 2. **Pull of the New Solution:** What is the aspirational benefit the customer hopes to achieve with the new solution? This is the desired outcome. 3. **Anxiety of Making the Switch:** What are the concerns and risks associated with adopting the new solution? This could include cost, learning curve, or potential disruption. Risk Management in product adoption is vital. 4. **Habit of the Present:** How entrenched is the customer in their current solution? This represents the inertia that must be overcome.

Successfully "hiring" a product requires the "pull" forces (pull of the new solution) to outweigh the "push" and "anxiety" forces (push of the situation, anxiety of making the switch) and overcome the habit of the present. A strong JTBD strategy aims to maximize the pull and minimize the anxiety.

Uncovering the "Job" – Interviewing for Progress

Identifying the "job" requires a specific type of interviewing technique. Traditional market research asking customers what they want often fails because customers aren’t consciously aware of the underlying jobs they are trying to accomplish. They can only articulate their problems or desired features.

JTBD interviews focus on *struggling moments* – times when the customer was trying to make progress and faced obstacles. These interviews aren’t about asking customers about their demographics or opinions; they’re about reconstructing the timeline of events that led them to "hire" a product. Key questions include:

• **First Thought:** What was the first thought that sparked your interest in finding a solution?
• **Timeline:** Walk me through the steps you took to find and choose this product.
• **Struggling Moments:** What were the biggest obstacles you faced? What were you trying to achieve at each stage?
• **Alternatives Considered:** What other solutions did you consider, and why did you reject them?
• **Compensating Behaviors:** What workarounds or hacks did you use before finding this solution?

The goal is to understand the *context* in which the "job" arises, the *struggle* the customer experienced, and the *progress* they were trying to make. Qualitative Data Analysis is essential for extracting meaningful insights from these interviews.

JTBD vs. Traditional Segmentation

The JTBD framework differs significantly from traditional segmentation approaches:

| Feature | Traditional Segmentation | Jobs to Be Done | |---|---|---| | **Focus** | Who the customer is | Why the customer hires a product | | **Basis** | Demographics, Psychographics | Underlying progress the customer is trying to make | | **Insight** | Describes customer groups | Reveals unmet needs and opportunities for innovation | | **Marketing** | Targeting specific segments | Positioning products to address specific jobs | | **Innovation** | Incremental improvements to existing products | Radical innovation by addressing underserved jobs |

Traditional segmentation can be useful for targeting marketing messages, but it often fails to explain *why* customers choose one product over another. JTBD provides a deeper understanding of customer motivation, leading to more effective product development and marketing strategies. Competitive Analysis benefits from a JTBD perspective, revealing competing solutions beyond direct product rivals.

Practical Application: Product Development & Marketing

The JTBD framework has significant implications for both product development and marketing:

• **Product Development:** Instead of asking "What features should we add?", ask "What job are our customers trying to get done?" This shifts the focus from features to outcomes. Prioritize features that directly address the core job and minimize the forces hindering adoption. Agile Development methodologies can be effectively combined with JTBD principles.
• **Marketing:** Instead of focusing on demographics or benefits, focus on the "job story" – a narrative that describes the struggle, the solution, and the progress achieved. Marketing messages should resonate with the emotional and social dimensions of the job. Content Marketing can be used to tell compelling job stories. Consider using frameworks like AIDA (Attention, Interest, Desire, Action) but framed around the JTBD.
• **Innovation:** JTBD can identify underserved jobs that represent opportunities for disruptive innovation. By focusing on jobs that are currently poorly addressed, companies can create new markets and capture new customers. Blue Ocean Strategy complements the JTBD framework by seeking uncontested market spaces.
• **Pricing:** Pricing should reflect the value the product delivers in helping the customer get the job done. Value-Based Pricing aligns pricing with the perceived benefit to the customer.

Tools and Techniques for JTBD Implementation

Several tools and techniques can facilitate JTBD implementation:

• **Job Story Mapping:** A visual tool for mapping out the customer’s journey and identifying the jobs they are trying to get done at each stage.
• **Force Field Analysis:** A technique for identifying the forces that are driving and restraining progress.
• **Opportunity Solution Tree:** A framework for breaking down a job into smaller sub-jobs and identifying potential solutions.
• **Customer Journey Mapping:** While similar, JTBD-focused journey maps concentrate on the progress customers are attempting to make, not just the steps they take.
• **Jobs-to-be-Done Interviewing Guides:** Structured interview protocols designed to elicit insights into the customer’s struggle and progress.

Advanced Concepts

• **Job Hierarchy:** Jobs are often nested. A customer might hire a product to do a core job, which is in turn a step towards achieving a larger, more aspirational job.
• **Job Executors:** Sometimes, the customer isn't the direct user of the product. The "job executor" is the person who actually uses the product, while the "buyer" is the person who pays for it. Understanding both roles is crucial.
• **Job Context:** The specific circumstances in which the job arises can significantly influence the customer’s decision.

JTBD and Other Frameworks

The JTBD framework is compatible with and complements other frameworks:

• **Lean Startup:** JTBD helps identify the right problems to solve, while Lean Startup provides a methodology for iteratively building and testing solutions. Minimum Viable Product (MVP) development benefits from JTBD insights.
• **Design Thinking:** JTBD provides a deeper understanding of customer needs, which can inform the empathy and ideation phases of Design Thinking.
• **Business Model Canvas:** JTBD can inform the Value Proposition element of the Business Model Canvas, ensuring that the product is designed to address a real customer job.
• **Five Forces Analysis:** While primarily a strategic tool, understanding the jobs customers are trying to get done can provide insights into the bargaining power of buyers and suppliers.
• **SWOT Analysis:** JTBD can help identify opportunities and threats by revealing unmet customer needs and competitive vulnerabilities.
• **Porter's Five Forces:** Understanding the "job" can help you determine the competitive landscape and potential for differentiation.

Limitations and Considerations

While powerful, the JTBD framework isn’t without limitations:

• **Complexity:** Uncovering the underlying "job" can be challenging and requires skilled interviewing and analysis.
• **Context Dependency:** Jobs can vary depending on the context, making it difficult to generalize findings.
• **Not a Replacement for Market Research:** JTBD should be used in conjunction with other market research methods, not as a replacement.
• **Requires a Shift in Mindset:** Adopting the JTBD framework requires a fundamental shift in how organizations think about customers and innovation.

For further reading:

• **Clayton M. Christensen’s *Competing Against Luck*:** [1]
• **Strategyn:** [2] (The company founded by Bob Moesta and Greg Bernarda)
• **Intercom's JTBD articles:** [3]
• **Alan Klement’s blog:** [4]
• **Jobs to be Done Radio Podcast:** [5]
• **Harvard Business Review articles on JTBD:** [6]
• **Nielsen Norman Group on Jobs to Be Done:** [7]
• **The Mom Test – Steve Blank:** [8] (Useful for interview techniques)
• **Inspired – Marty Cagan:** [9] (Product discovery)
• **Running Lean – Ash Maurya:** [10] (Lean Startup methodology)
• **The Lean Startup – Eric Ries:** [11]
• **Value Proposition Design – Alexander Osterwalder:** [12]
• **Blue Ocean Strategy – W. Chan Kim & Renée Mauborgne:** [13]
• **Hooked – Nir Eyal:** [14] (Habit formation)
• **Sprint – Jake Knapp:** [15] (Design sprint methodology)
• **Lean UX – Jeff Gothelf & Josh Seiden:** [16]
• **Don't Make Me Think – Steve Krug:** [17] (Usability)
• **Measuring What Matters – John Doerr:** [18] (OKRs)
• **Radical Candor – Kim Scott:** [19] (Feedback)
• **The Innovator’s DNA – Jeff Dyer, Hal Gregersen & Clayton M. Christensen:** [20]
• **Crossing the Chasm – Geoffrey Moore:** [21]
• **Positioning: The Battle for Your Mind – Al Ries & Jack Trout:** [22]
• **Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion – Robert Cialdini:** [23]
• **Thinking, Fast and Slow – Daniel Kahneman:** [24]

Product Management is greatly enhanced by applying JTBD principles. User Research is a fundamental component of the JTBD process. A/B Testing can validate hypotheses generated through JTBD interviews. Data Analytics can help identify patterns and trends related to job execution. Customer Support interactions can reveal valuable insights into customer struggles. Market Segmentation is redefined through the lens of JTBD.

Start Trading Now

Sign up at IQ Option (Minimum deposit $10) Open an account at Pocket Option (Minimum deposit $5)

Join Our Community

Subscribe to our Telegram channel @strategybin to receive: ✓ Daily trading signals ✓ Exclusive strategy analysis ✓ Market trend alerts ✓ Educational materials for beginners